There's a lot of stuff on this page! Scroll down to see it all.
Important: The website has been experiencing problems with item prices showing on detail page.
You can still place an order.
Items can be added to the cart, and pricing shows up correctly. Checkout and submitting the order show all amounts, and orders process correctly.
We hope to have this problem corrected soon. We apologize for the inconvenience.
Call or email if you have any questions.
Updated May 9, 2023.
Free shipping* on $50 or more. Enter coupon code FREESHIP at checkout.
Receive a $5 discount coupon for your next order of $30 when signing up. Coupon is sent in a separate email. (It is not an instant coupon, and sometimes there is a short delay.)
"Like" us on Facebook to be among the first to receive news, specials, and promotions.
Take a tour of the Tavern Puzzle studio.
How to order
Use our secure online ordering, or give us a call at 631-642-9092. We accept all major credit cards and Paypal. Website credit card payments are securely processed through Paypal; you do NOT need a Paypal account.
You can also print out your shopping cart order, or simply write out your order, and mail it. Credit cards and check or money order payment for mail orders. Sorry, we don't accept travelers checks, and we don't ship COD. Shipping
Most orders are shipped within 1 to 2 days. Orders received after regular hours or on weekends or holidays are processed the next business day. Personalized orders may take an extra day.
We ship USPS and UPS. Regular shipping charges are based on the number of items (see below). Please note that some items count as more than one for determining shipping charges (see individual item descriptions).
Expedited shipping charges (UPS 2nd Day Air and Next Day Air) are based on weight and destination. These charges can be previewed during the checkout process, before placing your order.
Shipping Charges (regular ground shipping)
1 item $ 8.95
2 to 3 14.95
4 to 9 17.95
10 to 14 19.95
15 or more 24.95
Local Customers: If you live nearby and would like to pick up your order, there is no charge for shipping. Please choose the shipping option Pick Up. We will confirm your order and let you know when it will be ready. Orders can be picked up weekdays only.
INTERNATIONAL SHIPPING ADDRESSES: Visit our recommended resellers for shipments outside of the United States.